OLS-2
mentor-training
Table of content
Name/pronouns/timezone
Malvika is taking notes and everyone is welcome to join in :D
What is mentoring and how does it work
Malvika
- Accountability, sharing insights from experiences, helping mentees identify right resources
- Communicating regularly, checking in and (re)setting and (re)evaluating expectations - which might change all the time +
- Gaining mentoring skills as we go along. Accepting that we don't know everything and my role as a mentor is to nudge my mentee in the right direction and not "push them" towards what I hope they would do. +
Yvan
- information about the fact that we (as mentors, maybe new in this function) can be mentoring someone -> going from maker towards helper, something like that. For the mentee, I think this can give more trust in their projects, as someone is there to ask questions and try facilitate the work of the mentee.
- mentors need to be there for the mentee, and give some time to help the mentee.
- mentor need to listen the mentee and be gentle ;) +1
Jez
- For the mentee: access to expertise, networks, feedback, alternative viewpoints; for the mentor: contribute to a community, build someone's confidence, "give back"
- Roles/responsibilities/expectations can be very variable, need to be discussed afresh within each mentoring partnership
- Open and flexible mind-set: need to be supportive of the mentee and empower them, not impose wht you think might be the "right" thing to do
Arielle
- Mentoring is a mutual growth jounrey that produces or develops new perspectives on problems or projects +
- Role of mentor: Not solving the mentees problems yourself, instead offering tools and approaches to support the mentee, an outside perspective (sometimes neutral), encouraging the mentee to push themselves. Mentee: willing to take onboard the feedback from the mentor and trial it, looking to support but not handholding +
- Skills: active listening, probing questions, problem-solving approaches, collaborative mindset, critical thinking, emotional intelligence
Renato
- Experience, Lead by example, External perspective, rapport.
- Challenging… should be discussed case-by-case - good communication. Manage expectation…
- Critical thinking. Provocative questions. Forward/future looking - vision. Problem/challenge solving.
Anelda
- Understanding of other people's experiences, challenges, and view points - especially people in other career types/roles/career stages;
- Mentor: Support, confidence grower, experience share; Mentee: open to learn and listen; active participant
- Empathic, patient, flexible, +
Sonika
- Helping someone less experienced achieve their professional goals. (notes: provide information advise, guide. sounding board)
- Together: Setting short/long term goals and expectations.Mentor: non-judgemental, supportive, flexible Mentee: open to feedback, respectful, willing to take an active role
- Devloping trust relationship.
Markus
- personal development, reflection on personal development
- mentee: openness to learn, commitment to spend time/effort on learning; mentor: understanding of own limits of expertise, understanding of mentee's progress and needs
- confidence to acknowledge one's own limits, openness to learn from mentee
David
- Increasing confidence, access to increased professional networks and relationships, increased learning. +
- Existence of trust, regular check-ins, establishing clear goals and objectives, clear channels of communication
- Being more of a listener than a talker; employing skills that makes the mentee the centre of focus
Notes
Mentoring | Coaching |
---|---|
Advising - Provide advice & guidance | Asking - Facilitate following a process |
Tend to have expertise in the subject | Coaches don't need to have expertise at all to coach someone (theoretically can coach anyone in anything) |
Share experience & guide a less-experienced colleague | Coaches may ask questions that can unlock a thought process unlike your own (constructive manner) |
May also use coaching skills |
Mentor | Mentee |
---|---|
Chance to give back and share your skills | Get to learn from someone who you look up to (maybe want to follow the same career path as them) |
Listening skills | Access to network of people and expertise |
New perspectives | New resources or sources of ideas |
going from "maker" to "helper" | Opportunity to reflect upon one's own progress and learning experience |
Facilitate and make a contribution to something you couldn't achieve on your own | Build trust in a long term (safe space) |
Learn from mentees | Professional development |
Build network | External / outside perspectives |
Comfortable in asking difficult questions | Career advancement |
Malvika
Skills: Resilience, empathy, problem solving, collaborative, goals setting
Experiences: Community, team-building, communication, design thinking in research, bioinformatics, research
Lessons: Leadership looks like everyone know what they are doing, but the reality is that everyone is learning as they go along. Helping other (collaboration) is the best way forward but you also need to check in with your self every now and then ti identify what you have learned and what you have achieved
What did I get right/wrong? -
Stories: PhD life, immigration, studies abroad, cultural context, stories from different community projects, OLS
Resources: Professional connections, computational training, bioinformatics, mamangement tools
Arielle
Skills: big picture strategy, problem solving, critical thinking, broad knowledge about the scientific ecosystem, experience in both industry and academia, community management
Experiences: managing events, managing teams, dealing with difficult bosses, community management
Lessons: Learned a lot about working adjacent to research, community management, I've got a lot of things wrong (but also a lot of things right!)
Stories: I have a lot of these…
Resources / expertise: specific networks I am a part of, different databases, practical templates
Yvan
Skills: technical ones and human ones (I hope ;) )
many experiences I can share, building regional working group / community(ies) to better understand issues regarding the use of some tools/concepts and learn things, keep people in touch between different communities / skills / managing team & project in academic context / creating a start-up using a "family"/user-friendly vision + open source and selling it to the major actor of the sector
learned a lot, every day. Learned that the manner I choose to operate (for my project/team management) is not so bad and maybe, at least sometime, better than others manners ;) + Community/ies is the more important (but I was thinking that from the beginning ;) !
almost everything got right! Even potential failures were real good points!
Each story related to my experiences can make my point ;)
Resources/expertise… good question!
Sonika
Skills: people/project management, problem solving, networking skills, technical skills
Experiences:diverse experience in academia and industry, big geogriphically distributed team management, working with interdisciplinary teams, community work, organising conferences/workshop events
Lessons: importance of choosing right mentors at right time. Developing up and down networks. Work-Life balance. Handling toxic people/environment
Stories: followed a non-typical career trajectory.. lots of things to share.
Jez
Skills: problem solving, logical, analytical, technical, project management, communication
Experiences: data management in a range of different contexts; contributing to open projects, especially written word/documentation;
Right/wrong: have failed in the past to provide enough structure & ensure that mentees take positive actions out of each meeting
Festus
Skills: Problem solving, Emotional intelligence, Empathy, Logical, Management and Networking skills.
Lessons: Listening skills, Importance of having good guidance, Patience
Experiences: Community buiding, Event planning, Research
Anelda
Right/Wrong & Lessons: I used to get really excited about being a mentor and really wanting to help things along, so would literally take over the role of the line manager/supervisor and run ahead with a project in the way I think it should be done (not really the definition of a mentor). I had to learn to step back and calm down and take things slower and help the mentee to grow even if it meant not going at the pace I wanted things to go. I still have to check in with myself all the time to make sure I'm not forcing my ideas onto the mentee and almost planting seeds and seeing which ideas resonate with them and which ones they develop, then going at their pace but helping them to set goals etc and making sure we're making progress
Experiences: Working in interdisciplinary environments, working across industry/NGOs/academia/government (different working cultures), working with folks from different career stages, working across cultures (Africa, US, Europe, Australia), working with non-native English speakers
David
Skills: Data literacy training, facilitation, entrepreneurship
Experiences: resource-constraints/low-tech environments, development space, farming, global experience (Africa, North America, South America, Europe and Asia)
Lessons: it helps to be fully invested as a mentor.
Right/Wrong: establishing confidence and trust early on / taking on too many mentees at the same time
Markus
I changed the focus of my studies and supervisors in my PhD, because I did not find what I was interested in at first; in this situation, I often heard that it wasn't possible, but in the end I was able to combine topics and find other people who shared my interest and were willing to supervise me; made me become more aware of transferable skills and appreciate different domains/methodologies in science.
Renato
Skills: Domain-specific/technical, empathy, transference
Experiences: hard to say without a thread to guide it
Lessons: Knowing too much about something can be harmful. Listen for the content not the way it's being said (words being used)
Got Right: Adjusting the vocabulary/jargon to the level of the mentee,
Got Wrong: Resilience, overcommitting, amount of work hours.
Stories: PhD life, personal/work balance or lack of, failures & successes and lessons from them
Patricia
Skills: some technical skills in running services and events, some basic community building skills
Experiences: working abroad for several years not in my mother tongue and in a variety of research institutions
Lessons: plenty, mainly around managing expectations and scoping work
Got Right: Finding the right people to uplift you
Got Wrong: Still need to work on improving communication - constant issue
Stories: unfinished PhD, personal/work balance or lack of, failures and lessons from them
Notes:
How much of your story should you be willing to share?
Sarah: I think what is being said right now is addressing the uncomfortable feeling I have with “right” and “wrong” in this context. It’s a journey of learning and the fear of doing something “wrong” one of the bigger barriers to people participating in open science/open research
Renato: Loving the "bounce question back at you". Having big internal dialogs right now :) .Realizing that some questions don't need to be asked but also that making the right questions is hard.
Aidan: A question that I often worry over - am I (as an allocishet abled middleclass white man) better off mentoring other people with that demographic? Who I have a stronger link to the direct lived experience of and can work with them to see and work on mitigating the impact of their privilege?
What we need to do define/manage expectation?
Ask right questions
if the mentee feels stuck, help them explore their situation but don't do things for them
Duration of your commitment
Arielle
- Already met but started by understanding each other's backgrounds, overall aims for the project, specific goals for the programme and the challenges they've already identified with the project (OLS has a good framework for the opening call!)
- Will need to revisit this but: what are you hoping to get out of our discussions?
- We have agreed a clear goal for the end of the programme so I think we'll take some time to check in with the progress and discuss any difficulties / roadblocks they've encountered
Malvika
- Learning about what project they wanna work on, what goals they have set for themselves
- Share with them what my role will be, how best we can use our meetings and time in OLS
- Asking them about their learning process, how they are applying those skills in their work, checking in to see how they are feeling about their development
Patricia
Already met the mentee but more of an introduction and trying to understand where the planned project fits with their other priorities, I always find expectations a bit hard when they have no real understanding of the programme and also have never had a mentorship relationship. Will need to go back and do some more expectation setting and focus more on actions.
Anelda
- Already met with mentee. First conversation was really about who they are, where they are at, and learning about their project. Also for them to learn about who I am, where I'm at because we're in very different parts of the world and also in very different jobs
- We looked at the framework and guidelines provided by OLS and agree that we'll follow their suggestions as closely as possible to manage expectations. We're both comfortable with the way the programme is structured.
- We've met 3 times and have a little ritual to get us started (each share one good thing that happened the past week in personal life and in work). Then we discuss the homework she had and then we plan what she could do in the week to come until we meet again. Next week she will share with me her idea of what it will look like if the programme is successful for her project. Then we'll figure out how to go about achieving that. She takes a lot of ownership which I really appreciates.
Jez
- Already done! Followed the provided agenda: introductions all round, discuss expectations & goals
- What do you want to achieve? What gaps do you have in your knowledge/skills? What do you think I can help with?
- Concrete actions & timescales (driven by mentees); regular meetings
Yvan
- already done, "just" introducing ourselves and try laugh a little bit
- what is your project and goals
- oganizing regular meetings
Markus
- already done; ask for introductions to get to know them a bit better, their background, interests and hopes for the OLS programme
- how can I help you? what things do you need help with? making concrete suggestions about what to discuss in the next calls
- write down goals, agenda/objectives for next meeting, ask if objectives have been fulfiled in meeting
Sonika
- introducing yourself and your background briefly. Understanding mentees project and expectations and goals.
- Goal setting may also be done in the first call
- setting roles and responsibilities.
- length and frequency of conversations/meetings
Renato
- Introduction, who everyone is, and where they came from. Get the chemistry going…
- Where do you want to be at the end of the programme?
Discussing the purpose of the call.
Progress update. Not for pressure but for guidance.- The guiding doc from OLS was super helpful!! . Have a doc structured with a couple of points to guide. Reschedule what hasn't been covered and update with anything relevant.
Notes
Open Question:
Mentee can have exploratory questions and answers - explore their thoughts more deeply:
Closed Question:
Defined specific answer (yes/no) - commitment questions inhibit people to think depper: Can/do/have you …?
Arielle: I try but I'm not a consistently good listener! +10000 by many people
Renato: over empathising often gets me in trouble… feeling the struggles and wanting to actively help (hands on).
Jez: body language doesn't always reflect what people might be thinking
Capture essence of the conversation when you think your mentee is vague and is struggling to put their thought across
Summarising conversation: role playing
Notes
It's about your mentee's experience and the value they get out of that
Role-play: 20 minute total
Practice using the mentoring model and skills: Feedback on one another and swap
Malvika and Yvan
"I understand that you have technical issue, and you don't have support from your team - and you have deadline" - "Did you look up for resource?" - "When I have this issue - I use XX resource, if it does not work for you let me know"
Notes
Assignments in OLS might not be very clear for the mentees - so it's important to ask questions around "what do you think you you learned from this assignment" - "how is this useful for you"
Community toolkits are relevant at different points - not everything will be useful all the time
OLS is like empty dessert that everyone is going to turn into Burning man
It seems to be harder when it is obvious that the person has already put a lot of thought into their problem and pre-empt the questions you were about to ask!
As a mentor you don't have to have the same experience or answer to everything, but don't underestimate your skills "based on my experience, how can I bring value to this discussion" - build accountability by shared thinking
Practice the questioning techniques - often as mentor we want to jump in and answer the question, but allow yourself to be surprised and delighted by the answers that your mentees can answer
Was that session actually mentor practice or just therapy for a lot of us? x
Notes
Typical challenges
Notes: The Role of acknowledging the spoil
Thank you! This was a great overview and has made me feel more confident that I can be a 'good' mentor. I only wish that I had done this earlier. Can you recommend any further readings
From Sonika Tyagi to Everyone: (1:01 pm)
Thank you so much, this was a great session. Learnt a lot
From Aidan Budd to Everyone: (1:01 pm)
I learned a lot very quickly and enjoyed it greatly. I am going to go back to my mentees and re-do the first conversation. THANK YOU!
From Patricia Herterich to Everyone: (1:01 pm)
Sad to not hear the answers to the questions - lots to think about though :) Also +1 for reading recommendations to keep reflecting
From Renato Alves to Everyone: (1:01 pm)
I wish I would have had this this workshop 5 years ago. Thanks a lot. It was awesome in so many ways.
From Yvan Le Bras to Everyone: (1:02 pm)
THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!
Thank you so much Tracey!
Really appreciated this session
From Lillian Juma to Everyone: (1:14 pm)
Thank you!
From Melissa Burke (she/her) to Everyone: (1:14 pm)
Thank you!
From Anelda Van der Walt to Everyone: (1:14 pm)
Thanks very much Tracey and OLS for organising it and everyone for your input and contributions and questions!
From Jez (he/him) Cope to Everyone: (1:14 pm)
Thank you so much!
From Markus Löning (he/him) to Everyone: (1:14 pm)
Thank you!
From Maria Doyle to Everyone: (1:15 pm)
Thanks Tracey!
Actions to take after the session