Generated using ChatGPT DeepResearch
TL;DR: Taiwan’s eID Project (2019–2023) – A Costly Failure
Taiwan’s electronic ID (eID) project aimed to replace traditional paper IDs with a chip-based smart card integrating multiple government services. Launched in 2019, it faced immediate criticism over security vulnerabilities, privacy risks, and lack of legal safeguards. Civil society groups, cybersecurity experts, and lawmakers warned that the eID could enable mass surveillance, data breaches, and even foreign interference, especially given reports that key contractors had ties to China.
Technical flaws, including a centralized data structure creating a “single point of failure” and potential biometric tracking, raised red flags. Politically, poor public consultation and rushed implementation fueled distrust. By early 2021, local governments refused to participate in trials, and the project was indefinitely suspended by Premier Su Tseng-chang, citing privacy and security concerns.
Over NT$1.4 billion was spent on development, but by 2023, the government paid NT$280 million in compensation to contractors, effectively terminating the project. Officials admitted that privacy laws and independent oversight were lacking, and future digital identity efforts would require stronger safeguards.
In response, Taiwan is now establishing a Personal Data Protection Commission and shifting towards a “digital ID wallet” model—a smartphone-based system expected by 2025. The failure of the eID project serves as a cautionary lesson on the need for transparency, public trust, and robust legal frameworks before implementing national digital ID systems.