# [EP 6.2] [Social] Replacement of Brantly Millegan as Director of The ENS Foundation.

**Status:** Draft Proposal

## Summary

The **replacement** of Brantly Millegan as Director of The ENS Foundation (the "Foundation Company").

## Abstract

This social proposal puts forth a vote for replacing Brantly Millegan with a possible successor identified herein.

This is a **contingent proposal** that will only be ratified if [[EP 6.1] [Social] Removal of Brantly Millegan as Director of The ENS Foundation](https://) determines that Brantly Millegan shall be removed from the directorship of the Foundation Company.

**Contingency:** If majority "No" is voted on [[EP 6.1] [Social] Removal of Brantly Millegan as Director of The ENS Foundation](https://), this proposal shall be null and void.

## Motivation

By a vote of the council, Brantly Millegan was removed as a director of the Foundation Company., the DAO shall decide whether Brantly Millegan is deemed capable, or otherwise, of continuing his role as the Director of the Ethereum Foundation, and to appoint a suitable replacement if he is deems incapable.

A timeline of events that led to this proposal has been posted by Community WG Stewards in another post [here](https://discuss.ens.domains/t/ens-dao-next-steps-re-brantly/10424/15) and quoted below:

> In May 2016, Brantly Millegan tweeted that, “Homosexual acts are evil. Transgenderism doesn’t exist. Abortion is murder. Contraception is a perversion. So is masturbation and porn.”
>
> On February 5th, 2022, brantly.eth, well-known as a prominent representative of the ENS protocol, [defended these views in a publicly held Twitter space](https://www.dropbox.com/s/ljrp0vjibawuufr/Brantly%20ENS.mp4?dl=0).
>
> Irrespective of one’s personal beliefs, we, as ENS DAO Community Stewards, must set the example for inclusivity and must not divide our community.
>
> Propagating rhetoric that is viewed as hateful and discriminatory is not conduct conducive to the role as a Community Steward. This conduct will not be tolerated despite one’s contributions to the protocol.

## Specification
The appointment of the incoming Director will be held by a [ranked choice](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ranked_voting) Snapshot vote from a list of pre-determined nominees. Additionally, there shall be an option for voters to select "None of the above" or abstain from this vote.

**Draft Ranked Choice Snapshot Vote**
>Who should replace Brantly Millegan as the director of the Foundation Company?
>**Choice 1:** avsa.eth
>**Choice 2:** daylon.eth
>**Choice 3:** healingvisions.eth
>**Choice 4:** None of the above.
>**Choice 5:** Abstain.

**Note:** *This list was randomized by @berrios.*

The nomination process for this appointment can be found [here](https://discuss.ens.domains/t/nominations-for-ens-foundation-director-to-replace-brantly-eth/10634), and a summary of Director's roles, responsibilities, compensation and liabilities can be found [here](https://discuss.ens.domains/t/role-responsibilities-of-ens-foundation-director/10632).

## Notice to The ENS Foundation

In line with this proposal, a formal notice is served to the ENS Foundation as follows:

*"Pursuant to Article 15 of the Articles of Association, the council, hereby, gives notice to the Foundation Company of the appointment of a director of the Foundation Company, to serve pursuant to the terms of its Articles.*

*Whereas, the council undertook a vote, via Snapshot, to remove Brantly Millegan,*

*Whereas, the majority of votes cast was to remove Brantly MIllegan and formal Notice given to the Foundation Company of such result,*

*Whereas, the council undertook a second vote, via Snapshot, from among nominees of the council, to appoint a new director of the Foundation Company;*

*Wherefore, the person, if any, with the highest number of votes cost is hereby appointed a director of the Foundation Company.*

*The results to be formally noted in the council records and the name of such person, if there be one, shall be promptly communicated to the Foundation Company without further process."*

You may view each candidates [delegate application here ](https://discuss.ens.domains/t/ens-dao-delegate-applications/815/1154) and comments in on nominees for directorship [here](https://discuss.ens.domains/t/comments-on-ens-foundation-nominees/10658).

## Next Steps

Finalize the list of nominees for the vote to replace Brantly Millegan as the Director of ENS and initiate the Snapshot ranked-choice vote ([RCV](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ranked_voting)) with a quorum of 1,000,000 $ENS.

**Note:** This is a Social Proposal; there is no on-chain voting. A Snapshot vote link will be added to this proposal when it becomes available.

**Note:** Nominees need not vote. Their votes will be cast for themselves as a redundancy measure unless they affirmatively choose to cast their votes for another nominee. Please consider redelegating your votes if you believe someone more informed than you on this topic would best represent your interests.

**Current nominees for replacement of Brantly Millegan in random order.**
1. avsa.eth (refer to the [nomination post here by @AvsA](https://discuss.ens.domains/t/nominations-for-ens-foundation-director-to-replace-brantly-eth/10634/12))
2. daylon.eth (refer to the [nomination post here by @daylon.eth](https://discuss.ens.domains/t/nominations-for-ens-foundation-director-to-replace-brantly-eth/10634/9))
3. healingvisions.eth (refer to the [nomination post here by @HealingVisions](https://discuss.ens.domains/t/nominations-for-ens-foundation-director-to-replace-brantly-eth/10634/3))
4. None of the Above
5. Abstain

**List Updated:** Sunday, Feb 27 2021 17:35 PST