My proposal is issued to address the following three central issues and other relevant problems:
Issue 1: Opening DatasetType to values other than raw and derivatives should have its own BEP.
Adding values to DatasetType is a major change to the specification that should be broadly discussed by the community, with a preliminary analysis of potential side-effects by the SG and/or Maintainers.
It took a long while before derivatives became a relevant part of BIDS and many years of discussion about them. I contend that DatasetType should keep its special status and be discussed separately. After DatasetType is agreed as the appropriate mechanism, the BEP leads intending to add values should state it when presenting the BEP draft to the SG before it becomes listed as an active BEP.
For instance, it would not be crazy to contemplate the possibility of having a DatasetType such as freesurfer, which has a very stable and standardized data structure, to allow it as a standalone dataset. Opening DatasetType means opening BIDS to the creation of standards within the standard. Where to draw the line between raw and derivative has traditionally be a contention point, so enabling more options should be considered very carefully, and provided with prescriptions of how to do it and how to decide beforehand. Otherwise, BEPs proposing new dataset types will creep up as we all tend to think that our area of specialization is special.
Please note that this issue does not enter into the actual value of atlas proposed by the BEP. That is reviewed next.
Oscar Esteban changed 10 months agoView mode Like Bookmark
Date: Feburary 22, 2023
Time: 6.00pm CEST / 5.00pm UTC / 12.00pm EDT / 9.00am PDT
Zoom link: please request to be added to the event messaging to <nipreps@gmail.com>
Agenda
Finally, official introduction of Elodie Savary, Ph.D.
Elodie has been recently hired as a Research Engineer to lead the development of cross-NiPreps infrastructure, taking the governance documents and their approval to the finish line, centralize the communications flow, and, in general, be responsible for all the action items regarding the CZI funding.
CZI EOSS5 award
We will walk through the aspects that have been requested for funding, see what is funded by this grant and what is covered by the R01 that started in June 2021, etc.
Elodie is transferring the action items from the project proposal into this GH project: https://github.com/orgs/nipreps/projects/4/views/1In broad terms, the R01 focuses on individual -Preps (fMRIPrep, dMRIPrep, ASLPrep, PETPrep, MRIQC) and underlying neuroimaging developments (e.g., SDCFlows) while the EOSS5 focuses on community building and scientific software engineering aspects.
Taylor Salo changed 2 years agoEdit mode Like Bookmark
Date: April 14, 2021
Time: 6.00pm CEST / 4.00pm UTC / 12.00pm EDT / 9.00am PDT
URL: [redacted]
Agenda
Welcome and introduction to the NiPreps concept (10min)
[preparation: browse the website www.nipreps.org if you can]
Ongoing NiPreps projects (5min):fMRIPrep (https://github.com/nipreps/fmriprep)
dMRIPrep (https://github.com/nipreps/dmriprep)
NiBabies (core utilities to build f/dMRIPreps for infants; (https://github.com/nipreps/nibabies))
Oscar Esteban changed 2 years agoView mode Like Bookmark
# dMRIPrep Workshop Agenda
## Participants
* Ariel Rokem (organizer, Tel: 5103876264)
* Anisha Keshavan
* Adam Richie-Halford
* Oscar Esteban
* Garikoitz Lerma-Usabiaga
* Derek Pilsner
* Michael Joseph
* Matthew Cieslak
* Ross Lawrence
* (please add your name if not listed)
## Tasks
(from the [Shared Document])
1. **B0 reference of each `run-` & brain extraction from that** ([#25]): finalize (if not done before the workshop).
* Grand mean scaling? (working on this on NiWorkflo
Oscar Esteban changed 5 years agoEdit mode Like Bookmark