Part of a presentation on Coalgebras over Lawvere Metric Spaces
How far can we push the observation that the notions of behavioural equivalence can be generalised using enriched category theory?
As suggested by Rutten (1998) and Worrell (2000) a fruitful level of generality is coalgebras over the category of categories enriched over a quantale .
Lawvere metric spaces are one of the most interesting examples of categories enriched over a quantale.
Metric Spaces, Generalized Logic, and Closed Categories:
Lawvere focusses in his paper on the quantale where is top and the quantale-multiplication is addition, but his ideas can be applied to any quantale.
For the remainder of this presentation we follow our article Extending set functors to generalised metric spaces., where all details and references can be found.
A quantale is a complete lattice with an order-preserving 'multiplication' and neutral element such that and have right adjoints for all .
Intuitively, we may think of the order as representing (i) logical impliciation, being closer to truth than or (ii) being a greater distance than . In the latter case is addition of distances and the internal hom is if and, otherwise, how much further from truth is than .
The paradigmatic example for the distance interpretation is the subset of real numbers with addition as multiplication and truncated minus as internal hom.
The categories enriched over are known as Lawvere metric spaces. If one uses minimum instead of addition as tensor one obtains Lawvere ultrametric spaces.
The following shows an example with a non symmetric distance.
Example: Let be the set of finite and infinite words (strings) over the alphabet . We define a distance on via if is a prefix of and, otherwise, where is the position of the first letter where is different from .
In this section we emphasised quantales as lattices of distances. On the other hand, not every quantale lends itself naturally to this interpretation. The next section offers a different interpretation.
Another way to look at categories enriched over a quantale is as relational presheaves. This point of view is equivalent to the metric point of view, but supports a rather different intutition.
Given a category enriched over quantale we build a relational structure on the set by choosing one binary relation for all , , satisfying
One can axiomatize those relational structures that arise in this way to obtain an equivalent, independent characterization of categories enriched over .
Example: Here are two quantales on the 3-element set:
On the left hand side (): The objects of an -category are events subject to a schedule, endowed with a preorder given by (with the interpretation that " happens no later than ") and a binary relation given by (which is intended to mean " happens strictly earlier than "). says that strict precedence implies weak precedence, while the multiplication law accounts for the prosset-law that implies .
On the right hand side (): The relation given by is interpreted as " precedes in time" and the relation given by is interpreted as " causally precedes ". captures that causal precedence implies temporal precedence and the multiplication law reflects that implies .
Example: Of course, one can also see Lawvere metric spaces in this way. This is closely related to uniformities.
Thousands of more examples are available in Jipsen and Galatos RESIDUATED LATTICES OF SIZE UP TO 6.
My longterm aim is to expand general coalgebraic methods to the quantale enriched setting. In the next section, we will look at one successful generalisation in more detail and the last section will look at one area in which many challenges still remain.
Here are some articles generalising set and order based coalgebra to the enriched setting.
The example of relational presheaves are due to: