Echoes of Atlantis and Númenor: A Comparative Exploration

The narratives of Atlantis and Númenor, despite their distinct origins, share profound thematic parallels that invite a deeper exploration. Both tales reflect the grandeur of ancient civilizations and the moral dilemmas they faced, revealing universal truths about human nature, ambition, and societal fragility. This article delves into the connections between these legendary civilizations, highlighting their similarities and differences in governance, morality, geography, and prophecy.

The Rise and Fall of Civilizations

In Plato’s Timaeus and Critias, Atlantis emerges as a formidable civilization, renowned for its architectural brilliance, agricultural advancements, and military strength. Initially, the Atlanteans, descendants of Poseidon, were just and noble. However, as their fixation on wealth and power grew, their moral fabric unraveled, leading to catastrophic decline. This narrative embodies the concept of Eternal Return, reminding us that the cycles of rise and fall are governed by human choices. It serves as a cautionary tale about the perils of hubris and the inevitable consequences of societal corruption.

Similarly, Tolkien’s Númenor is depicted as a realm of great nobility, favored by the Valar and flourishing under divine wisdom. The Númenóreans began with a commitment to wisdom and compassion but, driven by an obsession with immortality and hegemonic supremacy, defied the Valar, sealing their fate. This decline also reflects the cyclical nature of existence, as civilizations falter when they stray from their foundational values in pursuit of unchecked ambition.

Both narratives underscore the Eternal Return, illustrating how historical cycles mirror human moral choices and values. The splendor of Atlantis and Númenor serves as a poignant reminder of the fragile balance between ambition and ethical governance, emphasizing the importance of vigilance against the corrupting allure of power. Recognizing these cycles, we glean timeless insights into the nature of civilization and our place within it.

Governance and Ethical Dilemmas

The governance structures of Atlantis and Númenor reveal distinct approaches to leadership and the exercise of power. In Critias, Atlantis is described as a confederation of ten kings, each ruling a separate district but swearing allegiance to a central authority. This system balanced local autonomy and centralized power, fostering unity while allowing for regional governance. However, the harmony was shattered as the kings, driven by greed and arrogance, abandoned their oaths and conspired against each other. This collapse of leadership and the erosion of moral integrity illustrate the dangers of concentrated power without ethical restraint.

Númenor, as portrayed in The Silmarillion and Akallabêth, followed a more monarchical structure with a single king or queen ruling the entire island. Early Númenórean rulers upheld the values imparted by the Valar, governing with wisdom and humility. However, as successive rulers became consumed by the fear of death and the desire for immortality, they grew tyrannical, rejecting the guidance of the Valar and enforcing oppressive laws. The later kings, such as Ar-Pharazôn, exemplify the perils of despotic rule driven by pride and jealousy.

In both societies, the breakdown of governance was accompanied by a decline in moral values, highlighting a central theme: true leadership requires more than just strength or authority; it demands adherence to higher ethical standards. When leaders prioritize personal gain or fear-driven decisions over the well-being of their people, the resulting corruption can lead to the unraveling of even the most powerful empires.

The Role of Religion and Mythology

Religion and mythology serve as cornerstones in the narratives of Atlantis and Númenor, defining their values, influencing decisions, and determining their fates. Plato’s account of Atlantis situates the story within a theological framework, attributing the rise and fall to the will of the gods. Atlantis was established by Poseidon, who divided the land among his sons and established divine laws. Over time, the Atlanteans forsake these principles, becoming more focused on material wealth and power, ultimately corrupting the divine order. Their moral decay is framed as an offense against the gods, and their punishment—a catastrophic deluge—is depicted as divine retribution.

Similarly, Númenor’s history is steeped in its relationship with the divine Valar and Eru Ilúvatar. The island was a gift to the Edain for their service in the wars against Morgoth, and the Númenóreans were blessed with long life and knowledge. This special relationship established a quasi-religious bond, represented by their reverence for Eru Ilúvatar and the practice of ascending Meneltarma, the Sacred Mountain, to offer prayers and thanksgiving.

However, the Númenóreans’ faith wavered. Envious of the immortality of the Elves and the inhabitants of Aman, they turned against the Valar under the influence of Sauron. The last King, Ar-Pharazôn, rejected the worship of Eru, constructing a massive temple dedicated to Morgoth and performing human sacrifices. This desecration led to Númenor’s ultimate fall, with Eru Ilúvatar intervening to destroy the island and reshape the world.

The mythological elements in both stories illustrate the civilizations’ relationships with higher powers and their understanding of their place in the cosmos. For Atlantis, it is the violation of Poseidon’s laws that leads to ruin; for Númenor, it is the rejection of the Valar’s wisdom and the hubris of trying to transcend mortal limitations. Both stories use religious decline as the catalyst for destruction, emphasizing that true power and stability come from maintaining a harmonious relationship with the divine.

Environmental and Geological Aspects

The geographical and environmental aspects of Atlantis and Númenor’s downfall are crucial to understanding their narratives. Both stories incorporate cataclysmic events that reshape the physical world and the civilizations’ perceptions of their place in it. While the legends are mythical, their descriptions bear striking similarities to real-world geological events, making them compelling.

Atlantis: Geological Destruction and Sea-Level Changes

Plato’s description of Atlantis’s destruction involves a massive earthquake and subsequent flooding that caused the island to sink beneath the waves in a single day and night. This event has led many to speculate about its basis in real geological phenomena, particularly those involving tectonic shifts, volcanic activity, and rapid sea-level changes.

One significant geological event that might have inspired Plato’s narrative is the end of the last Ice Age around 9600 BCE. During this period, the melting of massive ice sheets caused sea levels to rise by up to 120 meters, submerging large coastal areas and islands. The timing of these events coincides closely with Plato’s proposed date for the fall of Atlantis, suggesting a possible link between myth and reality.

Moreover, this period witnessed increased tectonic activity and volcanic eruptions. The release of tectonic pressure as glaciers retreated could have triggered earthquakes and tsunamis, adding to the devastation. While there is no direct evidence of a sunken island the size of Atlantis in the Atlantic Ocean, the narrative’s description of geological upheaval parallels the natural disasters that would have left a lasting impression on early human societies.

Archaeological discoveries, such as Doggerland, a now-submerged landmass that once connected Britain to mainland Europe, further support the idea of lost civilizations submerged by rising seas. Around 8200 BCE, rising sea levels led to the flooding of Doggerland, permanently altering the region’s geography. Similar phenomena could have inspired the story of a vanished island civilization that Plato elaborated upon.

Númenor: A Lost Land and the Reshaping of the World

In Tolkien's Legendarium, the destruction of Númenor is a cosmic event that not only submerges the island but reshapes the entire world. Eru Ilúvatar's intervention transforms Arda from a mythological flat world to a factual sphere, placing Aman and the Blessed Realm beyond mortal reach. This dramatic restructuring underscores the severity of Ar-Pharazôn and his people's transgressions.

While the eruption of Thera (modern-day Santorini) around 1600 BCE is often cited as a possible inspiration for Númenor's fall, recent geological evidence points to an even more catastrophic event. Approximately 520,000 years ago, an ancient eruption released pyroclastic flows ten times greater than those of the 2022 Hunga Tonga-Hunga Ha'apai eruption. The scale of this prehistoric catastrophe aligns more closely with Tolkien's depiction of Númenor's downfall, resonating with the theme of a cataclysmic upheaval reshaping both land and sea.

Such a massive eruption could have inspired the tale of Númenor's destruction through shamanic visions, linking geological history to prophetic foresight (see our video "On Tolkien and Shamanism? The Approach via the Way of Arda's Lore."). This aligns with Tolkien's narrative, where the consequences of Númenor's transgression, and the resulting cosmic imbalance, reshape the world. The fall from grace brought about a fundamental alteration in the fate of the world, serving as a stark warning. Alternatively, one could say that the world's very fabric reacted to Númenor's actions, demonstrating the profound impact of their choices on the universe. The consequences were not simply punishment, but a profound and unavoidable reordering of destiny, echoing the themes of ancient myths and legends.

Ethical Dilemmas and Moral Lessons

The narratives of Atlantis and Númenor are deeply intertwined with ethical dilemmas and moral lessons, serving as cautionary tales for societies that exceed their boundaries in the pursuit of power, wealth, and immortality.

Plato’s account of Atlantis explicitly frames its downfall as the consequence of moral decay. Initially, the Atlanteans were virtuous and just, embodying the ideals of wisdom, temperance, and harmony. However, over time, they became corrupt, losing their divine essence and succumbing to greed and hubris. The Atlanteans’ expansionist ambitions led them to seek dominion over neighboring lands, igniting conflict with Athens. According to Plato, this conflict was a moral and existential trial for both civilizations—one representing self-restraint and justice, the other representing excess and domination.

The ethical dilemma faced by Atlantis was one of self-restraint versus unchecked ambition. The Atlanteans’ desire to control the world beyond their island ultimately led to their ruin. In Plato’s narrative, their defeat at the hands of Athens, followed by their catastrophic destruction, symbolizes the triumph of virtue over vice. The gods, who had once favored Atlantis, withdrew their support as the civilization’s moral decline deepened. Atlantis’s submergence serves as divine retribution, warning against the dangers of overreaching one’s bounds and losing sight of fundamental ethical principles.

Similarly, Tolkien’s portrayal of Númenor’s downfall revolves around moral choices and the consequences of violating divine decrees. The Númenóreans were granted long lives and wisdom by the Valar but were forbidden to sail westward to Aman, where the Blessed Realm lay. This prohibition was not merely a geographic limit but a symbolic boundary, representing the separation between mortality and immortality, the finite and the infinite. The Ban of the Valar was meant to teach the Númenóreans to accept their mortality and find contentment in the blessings they had.

However, as their power and knowledge grew, the Númenóreans began to envy the immortal Elves and the undying lands of Aman. This envy turned into resentment, and resentment into defiance. The ethical dilemma faced by the Númenóreans was whether to accept their natural limitations or to seek transcendence at any cost. The allure of immortality drove them to explore forbidden paths, including human sacrifices and alliances with dark powers, as depicted in the reign of the last king, Ar-Pharazôn. Their transgression culminated in the invasion of Aman itself, a direct defiance of Eru Ilúvatar’s will.

The moral lesson of Númenor’s fall is clear: to seek dominion over that which is beyond human reach is to invite ruin. Ar-Pharazôn’s defiance of the divine order led to the ultimate cataclysm—not only the sinking of Númenor but also the reshaping of the entire world. In this narrative, the destruction of Númenor is not just a punishment but a reassertion of cosmic balance. The world was made round, the Undying Lands removed from mortal reach, and the survivors—led by Elendil and his sons—were left to rebuild in Middle-earth, chastened by the loss of their homeland.

The parallels between Atlantis and Númenor highlight the shared theme of moral decline leading to catastrophic downfall. Both civilizations start as blessed peoples, favored by the gods or divine beings. Yet, as they grow in power and knowledge, they lose sight of the virtues that made them great. Their stories suggest that true greatness is not defined by material wealth or military prowess but by adherence to moral and ethical principles. The downfall of both Atlantis and Númenor serves as a testament to the dangers of hubris and the ultimate futility of defying the natural order.

These moral lessons are not merely warnings for the societies depicted in the myths but are meant to resonate with readers and listeners across ages. Plato’s Atlantis critiques the imperial ambitions of Athens and other Greek city-states, urging moderation and humility. Likewise, Tolkien’s Númenor reflects the existential fears of his own time, including the rise of totalitarian regimes and the threat of annihilation through unchecked power. The fates of Atlantis and Númenor remind us that civilizations, no matter how powerful, are ultimately subject to the same moral and ethical laws as individuals. When these laws are broken, the consequences are inevitable and irreversible.

Legacy and Cultural Impact

The myths of Atlantis and Númenor have transcended their origins, shaping cultural narratives and inspiring generations across diverse fields. Their influence extends beyond literature and mythology, permeating philosophy, art, popular culture, and even political discourse. Understanding their legacy offers insight into how these stories continue to resonate in contemporary society.

Atlantis: The Quest for Lost Knowledge

The legend of Atlantis has captivated thinkers from ancient philosophers to modern scientists, sparking a quest for lost knowledge and understanding. Plato’s account invites interpretations that range from historical analyses to speculative theories about advanced ancient civilizations. The enduring allure of Atlantis can be seen in the numerous expeditions, theories, and searches for the lost island that have emerged over the centuries. Various locations, including the Caribbean, Antarctica, and the Mediterranean, have been proposed as potential sites for Atlantis, reflecting humanity's desire to uncover hidden truths about our past.

The concept of Atlantis has also found a place in contemporary environmental discourse, often symbolizing the consequences of ecological degradation and climate change. The story serves as a cautionary tale, warning against human hubris and unsustainable practices. As rising sea levels threaten coastal communities worldwide, the myth of Atlantis prompts reflection on our relationship with the environment and the importance of stewardship.

Furthermore, Atlantis has become a popular subject in literature, film, and video games, inspiring countless adaptations and reinterpretations. From Jules Verne's Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea to Disney's animated film Atlantis: The Lost Empire, the narrative has evolved, adapting to the prevailing cultural attitudes and interests of each era while retaining its core themes of exploration and discovery. The mythical city continues to capture the imagination of creators and audiences alike, reflecting the changing values and preoccupations of society through its various incarnations in popular media.

Númenor: A Cautionary Tale of Pride and Fall

Tolkien's Númenor serves as a powerful allegory for the dangers of pride, ambition, and the pursuit of immortality. The fall of Númenor reflects broader themes within Tolkien's works, exploring the complexities of power, morality, and the consequences of defying divine will. The island's destruction stands as a warning about the limits of human ambition and the potential for moral decline.

In popular culture, Númenor’s legacy is reflected in various adaptations of Tolkien's stories, including Peter Jackson’s film trilogy. While Jackson's films don’t directly depict Númenor, they subtly allude to its downfall through the dialogue of key characters, highlighting themes of pride, decline, and the lure of power. These adaptations introduce new audiences to the moral complexities and epic narratives that define Tolkien's mythos.

Moreover, the myth of Númenor has found resonance in discussions surrounding colonialism and the quest for identity. The story reflects the consequences of imperial ambition and the fragile nature of power, raising questions about the responsibilities of those who wield it. This theme is particularly relevant in contemporary discussions about the legacy of colonialism and the cultural narratives that emerge in its wake.

Shared Legacy: Myth as a Reflection of Human Experience

Both Atlantis and Númenor share a common legacy as myths that explore the human condition. They reflect humanity's quest for knowledge, the struggle against environmental challenges, and the ethical dilemmas of power and ambition. These narratives resonate deeply with audiences, prompting reflections on our own societies and the potential consequences of our choices.

In essence, the tales of Atlantis and Númenor serve as mirrors reflecting the hopes, fears, and aspirations of humanity. They remind us of our vulnerability in the face of nature's power and the moral choices that shape our destinies. As such, these myths continue to inspire storytelling, scholarship, and cultural discourse, remaining relevant in an ever-evolving world.

Conclusion

The comparative exploration of Atlantis and Númenor offers profound insights into the nature of civilization, governance, ethics, and the human condition. Despite their different origins—Plato’s philosophical dialogues and Tolkien’s literary Legendarium—both myths capture themes that resonate across time and geography.

Atlantis, as an archetype of a lost civilization, highlights the consequences of human hubris, while Númenor illustrates the complexities of power, morality, and the fragility of greatness. Each narrative serves as a cautionary tale, warning against the dangers of overreaching ambition, the ethical dilemmas faced by those in power, and the inevitable repercussions of neglecting moral imperatives.

Geological and archaeological findings, particularly those related to 9600 BCE and the end of the last Ice Age, add depth to these stories by linking them to real historical and environmental changes. The concept of a sunken civilization, whether Atlantis or Númenor, prompts reflection on our relationship with the environment and the cyclical nature of human achievement and decline.

In modern society, these ancient tales remind us of our shared humanity and the lessons from the past. They challenge us to reflect on our values, the ethical implications of our actions, and our responsibility to the planet. By doing so, they inspire ongoing dialogues about the future of our civilizations and the moral choices that will shape their fates.

Ultimately, the enduring legacies of Atlantis and Númenor underscore the power of myth in exploring the human experience. These narratives serve as mirrors, reflecting our hopes, fears, and aspirations, and reminding us of our vulnerability to nature's power and the moral choices that define our destinies.

In an ever-evolving world, the stories of Atlantis and Númenor continue to inspire storytelling, scholarship, and cultural discourse. They offer timeless lessons on the importance of ethical governance, the perils of unchecked ambition, and the need for environmental stewardship. As we face contemporary challenges, these ancient tales provide a framework for understanding the cyclical nature of human achievement and decline, urging us to learn from the past and strive for a more just and sustainable future.

References:

Plato. Timaeus and Critias.
Tolkien, J. R. R. (1977). 'Akallabêth'. In The Silmarillion (pp. 255-272). George Allen & Unwin.
Nardo, W. (2023, March 16). Atlantis. Encyclopaedia Britannica. Retrieved October 6, 2024, from [link]
Tucker, M. (2023, July 14). Is Atlantis real? All That's Interesting. Retrieved October 6, 2024, from [link]
Hicks, A. (2023, March 20). The truth behind the myth of Atlantis. The Collector. Retrieved October 6, 2024, from [link]
Wakelin, J. (2023, March 7). Re: [AskHistorians] Comment on "Was there a real Atlantis?" Reddit. Retrieved October 6, 2024, from [link]
By Arcadia. (2023, July 3). Greek mythology: Plato's analogy of Atlantis. By Arcadia. Retrieved October 6, 2024, from [link]