---
# System prepended metadata

title: 'W3C Solid Community Group Solid Specification Meeting:'

---

# W3C Solid Community Group Solid Specification Meeting:
URL: https://meet.zrh.init7.net/solid-specification
CHAT: https://gitter.im/solid/specification

## Attendees

JB: Justin Bingham
SC: Sarven Capadisli
RV: Ruben Verborgh
DZ: Dmitri Zagidulin
TBL: Tim Berners-Lee

## Agenda

1. Status update on work in progress
    * PRs..
    * License (https://github.com/solid/specification/pull/89) (using MIT license, licensor W3C Solid CG)
    * WebID-TLS https://github.com/solid/specification/pull/140 (postponned to spec restructuring)
    * Effective request URI for POST https://github.com/solid/specification/pull/160 (near merge)

1. Server managed metadata
3. Panels and contribution

## Minutes

### Status Update

JB: Auxiliary resource received approval, merged into the editor’s draft - https://github.com/solid/specification/pull/156

SC: Resource access submission related to containment, shared slash, and URI persistence went through - https://github.com/solid/specification/pull/157

SC: Heuristic to determine resource type on post - https://github.com/solid/specification/pull/160

TBL: Issues with Slug
DZ: We should focus more on creating resource with PUT
TBL: Phase using Slug out
SC: Agree we shouldn't have to rely on Slug

Related to issue: https://github.com/solid/specification/issues/128#issuecomment-573033297

TBL: Propose that we should favor deterministic language, as opposed to making support for Slug behavior confusing to clients

SC: Revision currently in the works is in line with editorial feedback

SC: License (https://github.com/solid/specification/pull/89) (using MIT license, licensor W3C Solid CG)
TBL: MIT License is important - check with W3C for specifics

JB - Server Managed metadata - Proposal for basic information, extended information
    TBL: Basic provenance, Extended history may be flagged for future work. Consider an overlap with git.
    DZ: Third type - Access logs - who viewed/accessed - TIMBL +1, JB +1
    JB: We'll make use cases in interop panel and propose text
    SC: Put a condition on this - don't bundle all discovery into one server managed resource. Look at PROV-O. JB +1
    
Panels and Contribution    

TBL: Panels should be moving through things crisply and get them better defined. Chair could move things along. Chair represents the group, and is responsible for process, focus, action items.
RV: Initial mistake was to launch too many of them. Too much parallelization
RV: Important issue - text not evolving enough. Positive change is that we're seeing more text getting generated.
TBL: Reason is for us to make a more quality spec.