### Ipula

- Laravel Framework usage - good
- Good data-modelling
- code quality
- API only defining needed routes

- Documentation can be more
- Data seeding empty

1. Framework: 10
1. Documentation: 3
1. Overall presentation: 7
1. Authentication: 8
1. Data modelling: 9
1. Code Quality : 9

#### 7.6/ 10

### Aicha

- Presentation very good
- Framework usage: good

- instruction on setting root password forgotten
- symfony installation - forgotten, composer acceptable

1. Documentation: 8
1. Framework: 8
1. Overall presentation: 8
1. Authentication: 8
1. Data modelling: 8
1. Code Quality : 8

#### 8 /10

### Gazi

- Presentation good
- taking care of filtering good

- PHP 7.4 - Working with namespaces
- Simple authentication via email
- No framework
- Code Quality - HTML

1. Documentation: 7
1. Framework: 7
1. Overall presentation: 8
1. Authentication: 6
1. Data modelling: 7
1. Code Quality : 7

#### 7/ 10

---

#### Feriel
Documentation: excellent
Special: test classes
Authentication good

1. Documentation: 10
1. Framework: 8
1. Overall presentation: 9
1. Authentication: 8
1. Data modellig: 8
1. Code Quality : 8

#### 8.5