# Notes for session E4 at WalletUncon 2023

Title of talk: First draft for Wallet WG Charter
Convener(s) of talk: Kyle Den Hartog
Scribe(s) of talk:
Links to any presentation matter:

Tips:
- if you use github or gitlab handles instead of names, that allows scribes and conveners to be easily findable/taggable in threads when these notes get published to the CASA github org)
- preface remarks with name/handle and org if you WANT to be credited for contributions or ideas.
- feel free to call multiple people "anon" if you don't catch their names or they do not give them
- most scribes love an assist!

## Notes

- heirachical notes recommend
- for capturing flow

## Links

[document](https://hackmd.io/Y06R5sYpT5-F9v4loxB9ww)

### Initial requirements defined in discussion

# Wallet Working Group Charter

Now that Ethereum ERCs are separate from EIPs, we need to define a process. We will take inspiration from relevant processes, including EIP-1, but write something from scratch that is tailored to our specific needs.

## Goals / Requirements
- Record of decisions and archive
- "Principle of voluntarism"
- Wallets/Snaps/Dapps can ultimately do whatever they want! This is a best-effort basis to coordinate between wallets.
- Minimum 2 implempentations to finalize - enshrine test suite as the way to determine this
- Method to signal objection and way to override objection in finalization
- The ability to override finalization is done by an appointed group (similar to TAG at W3C)
- Need an Errata ability and/or the ability to make a standard living similar to WHATWG and version off a commit
- Proposals will be numbered following the EIP process
- Proposals will be expired if they are not finalized with a certain period of time
- A year?
-