---
# System prepended metadata

title: Initial ceremony.pse.dev feedback

---

# Initial ceremony.pse.dev feedback


Some quick (subjective) thoughts from Sam after checking out [the website](https://ceremony.pse.dev/) & contributing to the MACI ceremony…

First off, awesome work to everyone who contributed! Contributing to the MACI ceremony was surpisingly easy :clap: 

Goal of this scratchpad is just to offer some suggestions & constructive feedback on how we might improve the website. Feel free to completely disregard if folks disagree :smile: 

## Feedback

- Merge “p0tion” & “DefinitelySetup” names/brands?
    - Was a bit confusing for me (having heard of p0tion) to see the site labeled as “DefinitelySetup” (”are they the same, are they different?”)
    - I believe others on the MACI team (@ctrlc03, @Andy) have suggested that they could both be labeled as “p0tion”. It'd likely simplify things from the user’s standpoint & help with adoption to have it all under one name. Andy brought up the idea that we could ask for design help and try to build a strong brand here
- Add “About” page or some contextual info on what this website is, what it does…
    - Seems some info already exists at: https://p0tion.super.site/
    - I’d suggest we move that info over to live on the https://ceremony.pse.dev/ site
        - Perhaps not all of it is needed but looks like a good foundation
- Search bar
    - Pulsing red circle feels unnecessary…
        - Loading the page:
        ![](https://hackmd.io/_uploads/Sk-9VKsW6.jpg)
        
        - Clicking the red circle prompt:
        ![](https://hackmd.io/_uploads/Sk4jEtjbT.jpg)

        - Maybe just me, but it already seems pretty apparent that it’s a search bar. Maybe if anything we just provide placeholder text in the searchbar?
            - e.g. “Search for a setup…”
    - When searching from a subpage, the search functionality doesn’t appear to work
        - e.g. tried searching for “rln” from the [MACI page](https://ceremony.pse.dev/projects/Maci%20v1%20Trusted%20Setup%20Ceremony)
- Walkthough feature
    - Ah, after it pulsing over the search bar, I noticed it demonstrating other features. Nice!
        - For the rest, I actually found it helpful 🙂
- URLs
    - Current URLs
        - `https://ceremony.pse.dev/projects/Maci%20v1%20Trusted%20Setup%20Ceremony`
    - Suggested URLs
        - Something a bit more friendly & stanard, e.g. kebab case
        - `https://ceremony.pse.dev/projects/maci-v1-trusted-setup-ceremony`
    - Particularly if these pages are intended to be long-lasting & serve as a historical reference on how the ceremony was constructed (e.g. viewing contributions & stats)