---
# System prepended metadata

title: Untitled

---

## Peer review (Nemo)

### Name of the person reviewing
José Ocampo

### Name of the project being reviewed
SpotiStation
https://github.com/NemoAndrea/SpotiStation

### Feedback on documentation 
I should start by saying that I am new to OSH and Github, but I found Nemo's project to be extremely well documented. With my limited experience, I couldn't really find room for improvement, and I only have a couple of comments:
- the Manual (user manual) referenced in the readme file does not correspond with the description.
- if you already built a real prototype, it would be nice to see a picture of how it actually looks like.
- I think that at first sight, it might be a bit confusing that the system does not include speakers by itself. Maybe it should be pointed out more explicitly in the intro.

With respect to the readme file, I must say that it is one of the best readme files I have seen around; clear, concise and easy to follow, with several relevant links (I will definitively introduce some aspects of its structure for my own project).

Regarding ease of navigation, the folders structure is clear enough to find any file intuitively. But I think the links contained in the readme file are the best way to navigate through the relevant files for the project.

Assembly instructions are clear, starting with a list of needed components (including a bill of materials) and tools, followed by a detailed description of the assembling procedure. I really liked how at the end there is a link to continue with the software setup section.

Finally, all files for 3D printing and/or modification are available.

### Feedback on project 
After getting a little familiar with the idea, I really liked the motivation of the project; I think music can actually deliver peace and joy to people and it is fantastic to take it closer to people with the mentioned disabilities. Great contribution man!

I found the project to be in a really advanced phase and I think a first functioning prototype will be achieved during the programme duration without any problems. I even wonder if a first prototype has already been built.

The main goal is clear, and I believe it has been achieved. The desired improvements are clearly stated in the issues and initial guiding ideas for improvement are given.

I am only left with a question and a comment:
- Why did you went for a LED matrix instead of an LCD screen? Maybe some familiar pictures or nice landscapes could complement the music; I found some cheap LCD screens with similar prices to the one reported for the LED matrix.
- It could be nice to implement a button for adding songs to a favourites playlist.