###### tags: `Townhall`

*Sept 27, 2022, The Year of The Merge*

# 09/27/22 MetaCartel TownHall 🌶️

### Presenters:

- ~~[Bulla Network](https://bulla.network/) with UI369~~ Not looking for a grant so will reschedule for when boost is live and they can demo.
- Raid Guild collab.land/Zodiac Bot. Bau to present.

### New Member Proposals

- [Dermot](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/258) - proposal likely to fail
- [Bau](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/248) - ip
- [Pabs](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/254) - processed
- [twinFin](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/261) ip

### Member Proposals:

- [TBURD MCON Photos](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/260)
- [MCON Closing Party](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/257)
- [Shots Fired](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/256) - processed
- [Hats Protocol](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/255) - processed
- [MetaCartel Ecosystem Security Proposal](https://forum.metacartel.org/t/metacartel-ecosystem-security-proposal/2469?u=0x4d4n)- debate ongoing

### Funding Proposals

- [Community Health](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/259)
- [[Grant Proposal] Test DAO - Onboarding and Contribution Revolutionalized](https://forum.metacartel.org/t/grant-proposal-test-dao-onboarding-and-contribution-revolutionalized/2466?u=infinitehomie)

### Open Floor

- Demo Daze: Meta Cartel Twitter Spaces
- Info and team sigup: https://hackmd.io/@metacartel/ryBkoFz1o/edit

- Idea: radical quadratic voting. Upgrade to moloch v3 and give everyone v2 shares = square-root(current share #)

## Scribe Notes

### Bau presenting Bulla Network

- CollabLand isn't really in a position to build this out (capital and talent)
- grants are to facilitate this
- MC grant will fund Raid Guild to build this
- showcased at MCON2
- simple governance
- new proposal command, uploading and downloading
- Talent DAO tweeted about POC demo'ed at MCON2
- provide a framework to experiment with reputation based voting
- future: integrate with Snapshot
- Talent DAO will test, collect data, and provide research docs
- secure automated transactions in gnosis safe
- 40,000 discord communities and 6,000 wallets with CollabLand
- why enable a zodiac?
- veto power
- grace period
- upgrade to Moloch V3 (shares and loot with Discord)
- there's a Raid Guild proposal scoped
- stargarden is main developer from Raid Guild
- mantisclone is apprenticing with stargarden at Raid Guild
- penguin is dev from collabland
- $12.5K for Raid
- MC grant ask is $10K
- verifiable credentials issued through collabland bot
- CollabLand, Talent DAO and Raid Guild are sharing ownership and maintenance responsibilities
- repo will be managed by Raid Guild
- CollabLand will support Raid Guild
- Penquin is coming on to support this specifically
- CollabLand is working towards decentralizing
- curious about Talet DAOs role
- they want the thing built
- why aren't they making it happen?
- why aren't they taking responsibility for maintaining it?
- without clarity on maintenance, hard to vote yes
- experiments are useful, even if there's not clear maintenance
- open source is valuable
- Can we ask James who's maintaining?
- let's ask CollabLand to give back if they monetize in the future
- if it's a free and open source experiment, fund it

### New Member proposals

- Dermot is tributing 16.9 eth but there's more no's than yes's and most no's are from newer members.
- we don't know this person and they rushed it on chain
- should be 10 shares for 10 eth
- James vouched for him
- suggest he submit a new proposal for 10 shares
- Bau and Twinfin are both passing
- Pablo's passed and is a new member today

### More Proposals

- TBird requesting 1 share for taking MCON2 photos
- ecosytem security
- is it worth 1 share?
- only in forum
- should it go on chain?
- maybe he could also help with other MC communities as well?
- that could be worth a share
- Glitch event
- Community Health passing and voting ends in 11 hours
- Test DAO

### Demo Daze
- Demo Day on Twitter Spaces
- showcase things like Hats

### Public Nouns
- first auction Thursday
- not publicly announcing yet
- follow twitter if you like
- keeping it quiet and slow at first

### New grants
- for now, go through the forum

### recurring membership to fund MC
- came up at in person townhall at MCON2
- what about lowering eth requirements for new members
- why would someone think we're not responsible enough to give out grants
- why would someone want to buy more shares?
- mostly for signalling
- economic model to support a social club
- move away from buying shares
- one time thing, so not sustainable
- how much is sustainability part of our goal?
- how to keep funding side events at conferences?

### upgrade to MolochV3
- square root everyone's shares
- start the upgrade now
- should we have loot?
- MolochV3 channel