###### tags: `Townhall` *Nov 22, 2022* # 11/22/22 Meta Cartel TownHall :mulled wine and turkey: ### Presenters: ### Proposals: - [Minion sends a token, Requesting 30k Wrapped XDAI from Spice Bank šŸŒ¶](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/177) needs executing - [Minion sends a token, Requesting 50k Wrapped XDAI from Spice Bank šŸŒ¶](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/203) needs executing - [Minion sends a token, Requesting 40k Wrapped XDAI from Spice Bank šŸŒ¶](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/216) needs executing - [Swap WETH for wxDai, Multicall x2](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/224) needs executing - [MCON 2 Lingering Expenses](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/287) passing, voting ends an hour after townhall ends - [MCON 1 + MCON 2](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/288) failing, voting ends a couple hours after townhall ends - [Chili Pods (ETHos - Season 1)](https://app.daohaus.club/dao/0x64/0xb152b115c94275b54a3f0b08c1aa1d21f32a659a/proposals/289) passing, voting ends in 2 days ### Forum Proposals: - [[Grant Proposal] Inverter](https://forum.metacartel.org/t/grant-proposal-inverter/2661) - [ETHos, Chili Pod #2](https://forum.metacartel.org/t/ethos-chili-pod-2/2646) - [[Signal Proposal] Metaguides Revival](https://forum.metacartel.org/t/signal-proposal-metaguides-revival/2529/4) - [Wrapping up MCON Expenses](https://forum.metacartel.org/t/wrapping-up-mcon-expenses/2643) - [Proposal: Pixel Pooly | Public Goods Crowdsourcing Platform](https://forum.metacartel.org/t/proposal-pixel-pooly-public-goods-crowdsourcing-platform/2656) - [Grant proposal: ARTXV](https://forum.metacartel.org/t/grant-proposal-artxv/1974) - [3mo Retrospective Feedback - Scout Chili Pod](https://forum.metacartel.org/t/3mo-retrospective-feedback-scout-chili-pod/2635) ### Open Floor / New Business ## Scribe Notes - Chili Pods: - what's the metric of success and how is that judged? - is there a method to reclaim any unused funds to the DAO treasury? - minion module can be added - ETHos - better for a pod to run with it than have the whole DAO focus on IRL - give more accessability to people who bring value but can't afford it (not always just for people who can afford it) - grant to bootstrap and then have sponsors - is there any help needed? - post questions to the forum to get more insight - feel eratic to compare this positive sum with the previous suggestions to kill the DAO - Demo Daze is hosting wasabi and Bau this Friday, 1pm eastern - MetaGuides gonna try Charmverse - Charmverse is free for public goods - Charmverse has an open api - Discord powers got changed and there weren't any admins around to help bring a member locked out into the voice channel. - MCON request for shares - failing - already got shares for mcon1 - 10 shares = 1% of governance power - Yalor currently has 20 shares - 30% of the shares are with innactive members - Lingering MCON2 expenses - trying to clarify MCON accounting (sponsors and vendors) - there were more sponsors last year - some sponsors were turned away - not voting = delgating your vote to other people - What should be the standard for volunteers in MCON shares? - Do we need a bad guy to enforce rules? - we need roles! - how about hats? - Ven wants help to coordinate hats at MetaCartel - You can use social pressure to be the bad guy, but it doesn't come to anything when it comes to an actual vote. - if someone breaks the rules, an enforcer only has power if they have enough shares to vote the enforcement - if no one cares about hats, then it's not possible to enforce - All solutions are social solutions not smart contract solutions - can a newsletter clearly outline what's happening? will that help with visibility in what's happening. - visibility is hard - the enforcer can socially impact other members' votes - yay...proceedure! - are we trying to hire a fascist? - should be the person who least wants it - Q: So the dashboard that Iā€™m building will surface some of this: how much money in proposals each has voted through compared to sweat/contribution (calling this leverage). Also who has proposals that always fails, or always vote yes, common people that vote with them in a group, etc - Guildkicks were taken down - good faith action - hoping to see peth's thoughts in a forum post soon - we all appreciate the social aspect of MC - anyone can spin up a pod - appreciate the openness to receive peoples' passionate reactions - thinnly held together and can be precarious - would be sad if infighting led to the end - onboarder pod??