Initial response
I've little bandwidth for EA. The basic principle of EA sounds just fine: people devote resources according to their priorities. But getting into the weeds of their discourse is like asking me to mark a bad student paper for free w/no guarantee the student will learn anything.
— Ruth Starkman (@ruthstarkman) May 28, 2022
I'm not against the Big Util, nor Mill, nor many manifestations of it, but EA is not related to the tradition of normative consequentialism and higher goods after Kant. No EAer would rather be Socrates.
— Ruth Starkman (@ruthstarkman) May 28, 2022
Initial reaction
Seems like a lot of strong claims being made about thousands of people who are actually quite diverse in beliefs? Probably worth noting that seeing people make statements like this makes me update pretty strongly against how likely *you* are to "learn anything" from discourse :P
— Damon Sasi (@DaystarEld) May 28, 2022
To be clear, you don't have to care at all what a total stranger on the internet thinks. But if you're not aware that this is how your words might paint you to people like me, seemed worth saying so you can reflect on whether you are in fact OK with that perception of you.
— Damon Sasi (@DaystarEld) May 28, 2022