---
# System prepended metadata

title: Distributed Article Review Framework

---

# Distributed Article Review Framework

## Reviewer Workflow
- [ ] Reviewers receive access to Google Sheets files for `Project Manifest` and `Personal Review Log` and a Google Drive Folder for Articles called `Quarantine Articles (DO NOT SHARE)`

- [ ] Reviewers check out an Article by navigating to the `Project Manifest` then adding their name and updating the status column from _Uploaded_ to _In Progress_

- [ ] Reviewers extract insights from the Article that has been checked out in a `Personal Review Log` set up on Google Sheets. A good rule of thumb for reviewing documents is to 1) summarize main sections, 2) list specific insights (e.g., holdings, relevant considerations, histories, etc.)

- [ ] Reviewers submit their work for evaluation by Admins by navigating to the `Project Manifest` and updating the status column from _In Progress_ to _Submitted_

## Admin Workflow
- [ ] Admins upload Articles into Google Drive Folder for `Quarantine Articles (DO NOT SHARE)` and designate an article is ready for review by creating an entry in the `Project Manifest` and setting the status column to _Uploaded_

- [ ] After status for articles is updated to `Submitted`, Admins access the Reviewer's extracted insights from the corresponding `Personal Review Log` into the `Table of Insights`

## Links
[Quarantine Articles (DO NOT SHARE)](https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/folders/1hKyN-3dtr607Nc2XGOYn_L6fyctZZWUf)

[Project Manifest](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1bK77rqYoUP4GfN4Z0n6bj9FzZB7lSAEq6Mj9lSrlBLw/edit#gid=0)

[Personal Log - Template](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16n0cDqrLmwhvIjPOQa7RKEWETg2txA7ryYzGjh35GAo/edit#gid=0)

[Table of Insights](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1nE6YdjGahM7qtHMIBs4j7-uf8Oqllqz-sHAY4L0bem8/edit#gid=0)

[Example of concise statements of key ideas for other project on automated legal entities](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1nok9zJiHULGxcdo4z54pog0UvTYEoJGanmYL2lWrp4I/edit#gid=264630519)

------
------


# Key Questions for Articles

The top line questions are:
1) What have been the legal frameworks applied in the recent (eg SARS, H1N1, Swine Flu) and further past (eg Spanish Flu, Black Plague, etc) to pandemics?
2) What are some of the really the major problematic or dystopian measures that have been taken and what was their actual efficacy in managing the crisis (many articles report the efficacy was low in many cases)?

Directly below, there are also some augmenting questions based on a scan of the article but the reference to those sections was more to identify the parts of the article that looked most relevant.

What we need is a strip mine extraction of the top key points from those sections. 

## ABUSE OF QUARANTINE AUTHORITY.pdf
*Reviewer: Taylor Collins*

Article title: ABUSE OF QUARANTINE AUTHORITY: The Case for a Federal Approach to Infectious Disease Containment

* Summarize Section I. QUARANTINE LAW: A HISTORY OF STATE DISCRETION

* Summarize Section II: COMPREHENSIVE MEASURES: THE CASE FOR A FEDERAL APPROACH


* What is the "The “Model State Emergency Health Powers Act” (Model Act).  Can you find a cite and a link to the current version?


## AIDS AND QUARANTINE THE REVIVAL OF AN ARCHAIC DOCTRINE.pdf
*Reviewer: Taylor Collins*

Article title: "AIDS AND QUARANTINE: THE REVIVAL OF AN ARCHAIC DOCTRINE"

* Section I please summarize the history of quanrantine

* Section II please summarize the law of quarantine

* Section II C please summarize the major issues related to racial discrimination in this context and also discrimination in the AIDS context in the start of Section III

* Section III E. please summarize regulatory review 

* What are the key pointw regarding the _Spring Vs Hyde_ analysis 


## BALANCING INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS AND PUBLIC HEALTH SAFETY DURING QUARANTINE THE US AND CANADA.pdf

*Reviewer: Taylor Collins*

Article title: "BALANCING INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS AND PUBLIC HEALTH SAFETY DURING QUARANTINE: THE U.S. AND CANADA"

* What are the main points the author makes regarding the Model State Emergency Health Powers Act (MSEHPA)?

* What are the main issues related to Federal Government Involvement under the Posse Comitatus Act

* What are the main issues related to Federal Government Involvement under the Stafford Act

* What are the main issues related to Federal Government Involvement under Civil Distrubance Statutes (and what are those statutes?)

* What are the key Inherent Presidential Rights and Duties relevant to this crisis response?

* What are the main issues related to the Supremacy Clause of the Constitution and whether it has worked?

* What is different when a National Emergency (or state emergency) is declared?  What powers are created and what rights are diminished and how?  

## ANDREW WILL LOOK AT THIS ONE: BALANCING INTERESTS AND RISK OF ERROR WHAT QUARANTINE PROCESS IS DUE AFTER EBOLAMANIA.pdf

Article title: "BALANCING INTERESTS AND RISK OF ERROR: WHAT QUARANTINE PROCESS IS DUE AFTER EBOLAMANIA"

* What is the legal history for quarantining travelers upon return from a foreign location?

* Please extract the quotes from cases (one per row), what issue they related to and what is relevant about them today

## ANDREW WILL LOOK AT THIS ONE: DO STATE LINES MAKE PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCIES WORSE FEDERAL versus STATE CONTROL OF QUARANTINE.pdf

article title: "DO STATE LINES MAKE PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCIES WORSE? FEDERAL versus STATE CONTROL OF QUARANTINE"

## EPIDEMICS OUTSIDERS AND LOCAL PROTECTION FEDERALISM THEATER IN THE ERA OF THE SHOTGUN QUARANTINE.pdf


Article title: "EPIDEMICS, OUTSIDERS, AND LOCAL PROTECTION: FEDERALISM THEATER IN THE ERA OF THE SHOTGUN QUARANTINE"

* What were the responses to each historic epidemic (Yellow Fever, the 1897 epidemic, the 1905 epidemic, etc) discussed in this article and what were the main arguments made in opposition?

* Please extract the quotes from cases (one per row), what issue they related to and what is relevant about them today

* What are the main points regarding recent/current law described in Section IV. MODERN ECHOES: FROM QUARANTINE TO SYRIAN REFUGEES?

* What is the cite to the USSC case behind this quote: "the U.S. Supreme Court invited Congress to extend intrastate federal quarantine power by statute, but it has yet to do so."? 

## FEDERAL ENFORCEMENT OF MASS INVOLUNTARY QUARANTINES TOWARD A SPECIALIZED STANDING RULES FOR THE USE.pdf

Article title: "FEDERAL ENFORCEMENT OF MASS INVOLUNTARY QUARANTINES: TOWARD A SPECIALIZED STANDING RULES FOR THE USE OF FORCE"

* The "National Strategy for Pandemic Influenza Implementation Plan (Implementation Plan)"  is discussed on page 7 of this article. Here is a link: https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resources/pdf/pandemic-influenza-implementation.pdf  Please summarize the main legal frameworks it describes.  Is this still the current official guidance or is there a more current national strategy? 

* What are the issues surrounding Posse Comitatus? 

* What are the Fourth Amendment Reasonableness Standard issues?

* What are the main take aways from the following cases described in this article? 
   - Tennessee v. Garner 
   - Graham v. Connor, 
   - Scott v. Harris, 

* Wat is the Disease Identification Guidance for Quarantine Enforcement

* What are the main rules and issues regarding Due Process Requirements for Quarantined Persons?

## FORCED QUARANTINE And ISOLATION DOES THE LAW ADEQUATELY BALANCE INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS AND SOCIETAL PROTE.pdf


## FROM SARS TO EBOLA LEGAL AND ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS FOR MODERN QUARANTINE.pdf

## LAW IN THE TIME OF CHOLERA DISEASE STATE POWER AND QUARANTINES PAST AND FUTURE.pdf

## PANDEMIC FEARS AND CONTEMPORARY QUARANTINE PROTECTING LIBERTY THROUGH A CONTINUUM OF DUE PROCESS RIG.pdf

## PHASE SIX PANDEMIC A CALL TO RE-EVALUATE FEDERAL QUARANTINE AUTHORITY BEFORE THE NEXT CATASTROPHIC O.pdf

## PUBLIC HEALTH POLICY REVISITING THE NEED FOR A COMPENSATION SYSTEM FOR QUARANTINE TO MAXIMIZE COMPLI.pdf

## QUARANTINE AND THE FEDERAL ROLE IN EPIDEMICS.pdf

## QUARANTINING AN ASYMPTOMATIC CARRIER A REASONABLENESS STANDARD.pdf

* What was the holding and main relevant points in the Greene v. Edwards and Bradley v. Crowell cases? 

* What are the due process rights of individuals described in this article?

* What is the power of government and public health officials to act to protect the public from contageous desease described in this article? 

## QUARANTINING THE LAW OF QUARANTINE WHY QUARANTINE LAW DOES NOT REFLECT CONTEMPORARY CONSTITUTIONAL L.pdf

## REFORMING QUARANTINE MOVING TOWARDS A MORE ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE APPROACH TO OUTBREAK MANAGEMENT.pdf

## Right of one detained pursuant to quarantine to habeas corpus.pdf

## THE CONSTITUTIONALITY OF QUARANTINE AND ISOLATION ORDERS IN AN EBOLA EPIDEMIC AND BEYOND.pdf

## THE GLOBAL H1N1 PANDEMIC QUARANTINE LAW AND THE DUE PROCESS CONFLICT.pdf

## THE NEED FOR STRONGER IMPLEMENTATION OF QUARANTINE LAWS HOW ADOPTING CHINAS STRATEGY TO FIGHT SARS.pdf

## YAW PITCH AND ROLL.pdf


## Open Questions

* what has been the legal frameworks applied in the recent (eg SARS, H1N1, Swine Flu) and further past (eg Spanish Flu, Black Plague, etc) to pandemics?

* what are some of the really the major problematic or dystopian measures that have been taken and what was their actual efficacy in managing the crisis (many articles report the efficacy was low in many cases)?

* what legal measures are countries and states currently promulgating to combat the crisis (see the “CV19 Legal Measures” page for a starter on this, and we can use news articles with government published materials for examples extreme measures from China, Israel, etc and gradations of restrictions or required reporting from executive orders and new laws, including section 3224.

* GUIDANCE ON PROTECTED HEALTH INFORMATION in the US stimulus act enacted yesterday.


NOTES:

----

Article on Restarting the Economy and need for Antibody Certificate sort of thing... 

* http://connection.mit.edu/sites/default/files/publication-pdfs/Restarting%20the%20Economy_0.pdf


Task: Collect artifles from The 2017 Randolph W. Thrower Symposium Minding the Gap: Law and Practice in Public Health Emergency (we have one already)

* What are the powers of Parens Patriae for a state to act in a public health emergency? 