---
# System prepended metadata

title: "\U0001F4DD\U0001FA78 Sacred Oath Notes \U0001FA78\U0001F4DD"
tags: [Sacred Oath, ' Raid Guild']

---

---
tags: Sacred Oath, Raid Guild
title: 📝🩸 Sacred Oath Notes 🩸📝
---

# 📝🩸 Sacred Oath Notes 🩸📝
## 1/18/23 Meet
+ identify issues or unknowns in the HAT tree, what organization do we need to add to Raid Guild (e.g. Dispute resolution council) [figma](https://www.figma.com/file/ddUaNM1N3T2UzOoYSh4buX/Hats-%3C%3E-Raid-Guild?node-id=0%3A1&t=0gaHmydsB3MXhLkF-0)
    + Commitment Staking Contract
        + stake raid, recieve elegiability tokens, stake on raids, recoup/lose elegibility tokens
    + Cleric HAT
    + Raid Party HATs
        + Seperate hats for sepeate roles?
            + pros
                + sets baseline for skill tree
                + more data points
            + cons
                + complication
+ identify points for integration with Dungeon Master
    + pages within DM or seperate AP
    + Creation of Raid and Raid Roles as a 
    + staking for outside of DM
+ add the Rite of Moloch branch to the Tree
### Implementation
- goerli launch first
- zodiac modual
- Manager Hat contract
    - dev needed?
- PreReqs
    - DH v3?
    - Questions answered for the HATs team
        - Raid Staking
        - Commitment requirements UI for clerics
        - Commitment staking UI for Raiders


## 
- Pools
    - staking token is RAID
    - increasing liquidity for RAID
        - may encourage selling
    - 
- potential benefits (carrots)
    - Retroactive rewards
        - with the on chain data 
    - Slashed funds split amoungst members
        - partial split of 
- concerns
    - centralization 
        - one person 
## Talk with Plor review of Trello
- Utilize HATS for governance (act as an admin key, revokable seperate from contract)
    - each staking contract
- Contracts
    - Deposit contract
    - Staking contracts
        - modular but all able to interact with the deposit pool
        - different pools for different Raids, or RIPs or Responsibilities (e.g. Champion Staking)
- Ideas
    - Overstaking
        - e.g. 200% stake for what is necessary 
            - leveraged skin in the game
    - Incentive mechanism, not collatoralized/monetized
    - Slashing arbitration
        - Optimistic Slashing
            - Optimistic Slashing: Slash happens if no one disputes
        - DAO has the power to make the final say
        - Person2Person
            - 1. apply for a slash

            - 2. all parties submit evidence of the wrongdoing
            - 3. bring evidence to a tribunal
            - 4. vote is put on chain
        - Utilize Reality.ETH model
            - resoltion process that involves putting up stake behind positions
            - What is the percentage needed to win a round?
                - What is the math behind these models?
            - What is the token used?
## Materials
+ **[Plor's Scared Oath Investigation (Early Draft)](https://discord.com/channels/684227450204323876/1049762508090646630/1050450794060718201)**
+ **[OG S&C Pilot and Retro](https://github.com/raid-guild/RIPs/issues/75)**
+ **[RIP Proposal Sacred Oath (aka Stake and Commit v2)](/j2bp61NpS4CMuJNvnM9-0g)**


## Questions
### Stake
- What is the Stake Set to?
    - OG S&C was set at 5% of individuals Take home in $RAID. 
        - Reward was a match from the DAO's $RAID pool to the total staked from Proj
    - Current Stakes
        - Village People = 500 $RAID ~= $50
        - RiteOfMoloch = 50000 $RAID ~= $500 
        - ?? Sacred Oath = 100000 $RAID ~= $1000 ??
- Additional tokens
    - Implement a badge for successful compeletion of tasks/goals/ethc
    - opens up different workstream, reputation within the guild
### Purpose
- What is the commitment to?
    - If the commitment will be used to gate discord we are saying that its a general commitment to participate in Raid Guild. Therefore what are things that would preclude one from being a RG Member?
    - What are we trying to establish accountability for?
        - commitment over preformance
    - how do we distinguish between a stake to commit to:
        - Raids?
        - RIPs?
        - Internal Ops?
        - Meetings?
        - Votes?
- What is a slashable event?
- Need an additional layer for availability
    - Maybe the Stake shows that you are actively participating in the guild (attending meetings when possible, paying attention to #who-is-available, etc)
    - If we could implement an availablity metric then we could make that part of the Oath Keeper's responsibilities. Making sure that your stats are up to date
- Specific to Raids: bringing on fresh raiders the issue is BS'ed experience not flakiness
    - Different problem to solve, Raid Guild reputation measure



## Notes from 12/12 talk
- Need to define Rules
    - If this is denoting Active/Inactive
    - Distinction between Loot holders, Share and stakers
   - Votes
       - New Member
       - RIP Funding
       - Mint a SBT to Members
       - Guild Kick
- RFC
## Notes from 12/12 talk
- Next steps
    - Go through the pilot and retro from the previous Stake&Commit
    - Derive a proposal for the research and scoping sprint
        - [User Stories](/_VXKF5FcShqPWRgjcLNxIg)
        - [Review of the Pilot](/9bKQinhURwqeZc9t7lYMYA)
        - [Moonshot goals](/unWnj9kTTRegE4KnbKrvVg)
- Question
    - opt-in or mandatory?
        - How do we enforce mandatory nature?
            - Gating of the Raid Guild Discord 
            - Required for participation in the Raid
    - initial was opt-in, didn't get a lot of use
        - because of signalling or because it needs teeth
        - with opt-in and specific S&C to a specific raid there was the ability to incentize a new raider to take over for a slashed raider
    - Reward scheme
        - you don't want to incentivize slashing
            - more slashing =/= more rewards
            - slashes have a home in the general tithe pool
        - how to diversify the pool
            - slashes go to the tithing pool
            - more 
    - How do we offboard funds after good participation?
    - How do you get slashed?
    - What is the 
- Ideas
    - Tellor incentivises calling people out for bad faith actions
    - Uma (options trading platform) reliant on oracle
    - SLASHING is an ORACLE for this OATH
    - Consolidate Staking Contracts
        - Rite of Moloch
        - Sacred Oath
    - Could be the active/inactive members split
    - Target for Slashed funds
        - Sucessful slasher
        - General Pool
        - Fund for incentivizing new Raiders to jump on and fill the whole left by slashed Raider
- What are the distractions, how do we maintain focus
    - The Network

## Notes from 12/15 jam
- Staking holds reputation with it
    - should get good data over time
- Bidding to get on raids could lead to unfairness
- Should get a feel for how much $RAID members have
    - Also how much are people willing to stake
- What does research look like?
    - Initial push for Raid Guild buy-in
    - Final "shovel-ready" plan for devs