owned this note
owned this note
Published
Linked with GitHub
# MetaTx Crew Agenda - Meeting 0
Video + notes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tKOtWPopl8Q&t=3150s
New agenda: https://hackmd.io/WmHWgQDrSW6cgES9x2HXfw?edit
Since the creation of ERC-1077/1078, we figured out that we can do somepretty cool things with delegated execution of meta-txs. Many projects have sprung up surrounding this. So far we have had little communication between projects. There is a lot to be gained in doing so as we seem to all face similar challenges and issues.
Plus there is an opportunity to also explore the possibility of a permissionless p2p meta-tx network which will be srsly fucking cool.
## What we look to work on & progress so far...
- **Exploring the possibility of a permissionless p2p meta-tx network** where there is a decentralised pool of meta-txs that can be executed by a decentralised pool of service node executors
-> Austin & the Tenzorum squad have had an initial first call about this and have decide that the first step to take is to share how we have designed the meta-tx. So far TokenSubs (Austin), Tenzorum, Uport have uploaded their meta-tx designs here: https://github.com/austintgriffith/meta-transaction-format-share
-> We would love more teams that are working on this to participate and we are going to decide on the next step in meeting-0
- **Sharing problems** we have come across and how we can figuring out how to solve them efficiently
-> We have started to share problems we are trying to solve here with discussions beginning to take place: https://github.com/austintgriffith/meta-transaction-format-share/issues
-> Mainly about how to propagate meta-tx across service node network + reward economics / gas-reward dynamics & finding market equilibrium
- **Gathering a list of projects** & info about meta-tx / gas delegation: [LINK]
- **Writing up a blog post overviewing** all the different meta-tx projects out there. Currently in-progress by Golem, MP & friends.
- **We now have a telegram chat to join** When you join, please introduce yourself and share what you are working on: https://t.me/joinchat/HcTaOxJH6OzCna2UWJZo9A
## Agenda for this first meeting
*// Free free to add your own points, notes or even add to existing agenda items. Find this buttom on the top left side of the page to edit/add.*
![](https://i.imgur.com/6MTGy3k.png)
### tldr: get on the same page with language, define our problems and share our roadmaps in development
- **Define the language we use and get on the same page.** (gas delegation, meta-tx, gasless transactions, service nodes, relayers etc.)
-> Tenzorum has begun to create a definitions section here in their docs https://github.com/Tenzorum/.documentation/blob/master/TSNN.md#jargon--definition-of-terms
- **Share our progress so far on meta-txs and what our individual project/team project are at. What problems we are working on right now, what next, what is on our minds...**
-> Anything that comes up here outside the agenda is added to the bottom of the agenda for this meeting's call.
- **Discuss immediate next steps to achieve decentralised execution of meta-tx** (now that we have shared how we have designed our meta-txs)
-> Austin & the Tenzorum squad have had an initial first call about this and have decide that the first step to take is to share how we have designed the meta-tx. So far TokenSubs (Austin), Tenzorum, Uport have uploaded their meta-tx designs here: https://github.com/austintgriffith/meta-transaction-format-share*
-> Gather requirements of teams building meta-txs...
-> Set requirements for MVP, trusted parties only
-> Discuss the transportation layer of this protocol? libp2p, whisper?
-> Contract standard for establishing onchcain indication between fund contract (that pays for gas) and the public key that is signing the meta-tx. ERC725? Or a lighter more specific design?
-> What other considerations do we potentially need to share/standardise on for the decentralised execution of meta-txs happen?
- **Other problems surrounding the design meta-tx protocol** (This meeting we will likely just be defining issues and problems to solve then creating threads on the github for them.)
-> Problem surrounding service node Tx relay selection (needs algo to to determine which nodes gets Txs and how much / how often). Should this be designed on the p2p service node layer or the network transportation layer?
-> Consensus on tx ordering? batched POW of txs with trimmed header hash?
-> Service node staking, slashing? Service node onchain eth gas issue...
- **Decide on a org name for the github**
--- Meta-tx Guild
--- Inteplantetary Meta Wagon (IPMW)
--- FullMeta Alchemists
--- The Meta Cartel
--- Long Range Ballistic Transactions (LRBT)
--- Metascape Heroes
--- El Cartel de las Meta (ECDLM)
Plus official org site similar to erc725alliance.org?
## Recommended preparation for this meeting
- Read this whole page carefully.
# Details
**Date & Time:**
- Thursday 27th September, 5PM CEST (UTC +2)
please tally your timezone
https://www.timeanddate.com/time/zones/
CEST (UTC +2) europe: peter, sina, marek, piotr
EST Sydney: mark, Scott
MDT Denver: Austin
UTC-7 (Until Nov 4 / UTC-8 After Nov 4): Doug
UTC-4 (Until Nov 4) / UTC-5 (After Nov 4): Kyle
EEST: George
**Time:** 1hr, highly likely to go over this as a caution
**Meeting join link:**
https://zoom.us/j/537930220
For now join the telegram (Please intro yourself, if u don't intro yourself, I swear to god I will kcick you from the chat lmao): https://t.me/joinchat/HcTaOxJH6OzCna2UWJZo9A
**Attendees**
Pet3rpan
Mark, Software @Tenzorum
Marek, @Ethworks
(hopefully Austin, metatx.io)
Matt, Software @ Bounties Network
Tobias, Product @ Gnosis Safe
Richard, Tech @ Gnosis Safe
Kyle, Architect @ Boomerang Project
Sina
Doug King, CTO @ Verity
Piotr, Tech @ ChronoLogic
Julien, @ Argent
Olivier, @ Argent
MP, Meme @ Golem
Beltran, @ENS
Scott, @Gitcoin
Mokhtar Bacha, @fuel (Consensys)
George, @LimeChain.tech
James Young, @ SpankChain
**...add yourself, permissionless cryptoanarchy!!**